0044 — Outbound content: verbatim cards, never-grantable prefixes (v84-F4)
Status
Accepted (v84).
Question
The phase-2 shelf teaches outbound posting (X/Twitter, Discord
administration, email sends). A wrong post is public and permanent —
the highest-blast-radius side effect on the shelf. The v84 plan
originally said "the instruction IS the safety here"; the plan review
called that out: seeds are instructions, not enforcement. If the
operator ever grants allow_shell_command xurl, every post is
auto-allowed and no card renders anything. What mechanism guarantees a
post cannot bypass the card?
Decision
Two rules, one mechanism:
- Cards show verbatim payloads. Every outbound-content side effect — post, DM, email send, Discord message — cards with the exact final text (the F4 compose→card→confirm recipe). For shell paths, the card's full argv IS the payload; for MCP paths, the tool-call arguments are shown on the mcp-scope card.
- Outbound-content prefixes are never-grantable. The
git-prefix precedent (I4's shape) applied to posting:
OUTBOUND_CONTENT_PREFIXESinshell_prefixes.py(xurl— posting rides flags, so no prefix of it is read-only;himalaya message send/himalaya template send) is checked indangerous_prefix_reason: a grant attempt is refused with the reason at the persist path — presets, cards, and theallow_shell_commandverb all funnel through the same union writer, so there is no second door. The commands still RUN: ungranted, every invocation cards, forever. Unlike the git denies there is no run-time hard deny — posting is legitimate work; only the standing permission is refused.
Seeds reinforce (never replace) the mechanism: the social seeds instruct "never request a shell grant for posting", and the v84 seed grant-hygiene test pins a mutation-verb denylist (send, upload, delete, sync, post, push) out of every named grant shelf-wide, plus the rule that curl/wget are never a write path in any seed. Credentials ride env or the operator's own 0600 config — never chat; transcripts persist in the store.
Consequences
- "Every post cards" is now a property of the permission engine, not of model obedience — a seed edit, a confused Queen, or an operator habit cannot quietly create a silent posting lane.
- The refusal message teaches: it names the rule and the carded path (the v64-F3 lesson — an unexplained refusal reads as a retry prompt).
- Read-verb prefixes for the same binaries stay grantable
(
himalaya envelope list) — reads are cheap, mutations card.